Joshua agreed to terms different from Millie’s offer

33. Millie asks Joshua, “Will you buy my house for $150,000, with closing to occur in June?” Joshua replies, “That’s a great offer! Yes! I’ll give you $155,000, and we can close in May.” Has offer and acceptance occurred?

A. No, because Millie’s original offer was just an invitation to treat.

B. Yes, because Joshua agreed to pay a higher price, sooner.

C. Yes, because Joshua said, “Yes.”

D. No, because Joshua agreed to terms different from Millie’s offer, resulting in a rejection and a counteroffer by Joshua.